Friday, April 17, 2015
Craig Kimbrel isn't Mariano Rivera-Mitch Evans
.
4/8/15, "Mitch Evans: Craig Kimbrel Is Not Mariano Rivera," Atlanta.CBSlocal.com
"For all the folks in Braves Country that bemoaned the eve of the season opening trade
that sent Craig Kimbrel to San Diego, I understand the despair.
President of Baseball Operations
John Hart swore up and down throughout spring training that he wasn’t
looking to deal away the team’s home grown star, not even after he had
cleaned house in the off-season by making swaps for Jason Heyward,
Justin Upton and Evan Gattis.
The fact that Hart fibbed shouldn’t be held against him. It’s what people in sports management do. Call it the Art of the Smokescreen.
But in scanning through Twitter and other forms of social media, there was one theme that seemed to be at the heart – no pun intended – of the Braves fans collective disappointment: Kimbrel was comparable to the greatest closer the game has ever seen: Mariano Rivera.
Those fans need to stop it, and stop it right now.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Kimbrel has four fantastic years to his name. Rivera had 16.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Kimbrel saved 40 games or more in all four of his seasons in Atlanta. Rivera did it nine times, and twice after the age of 40. Kimbrel will be lucky to be still in a major league uniform when he’s 40.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Of Rivera’s record 652 saves, 119 of those were of the more than one inning variety. Kimbrel has zero.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
As we speak, Kimbrel has 186 career saves. For him to pass Rivera, he will average to average 45 saves per season….through 2024.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Kimbrel has one post-season save to his name. Yes, some of that is the Braves fault for not being able to get him more opportunities. But nonetheless, the number is what it is. One.
Rivera, appropriately enough to match his famous uniform number, has 42 post-season saves.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
So for all of those fine Braves fans who watched Jason Grilli save the season opener in Miami with 95 mph heat, but sat there and complained that he wasn’t Craig Kimbrel… remember this:
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera."
===============================
.
The regular season saves record won't be Rivera’s legacy anyway, NYT:
.
3/7/2013, "Next Step for Rivera: Closing a Career," NY Times, Tyler Kepner
In 1996 Rivera pitched 107.2 innings in regular season followed by 14.1 innings in post season including 3 days in a row in the World Series (10/21, 10/22, and 10/23) for a total of 122 innings.
Page 208 from Joel Sherman's book, "Birth of a Dynasty," about the 1996 Yankees, published in 2006 by Rodale:
"Most amazingly, of the record 4,962 homers spanked in 1996, Rivera allowed just one,
Rivera at 2013 Spring Training in Tampa, AP, via NYT
.
4/8/15, "Mitch Evans: Craig Kimbrel Is Not Mariano Rivera," Atlanta.CBSlocal.com
"For all the folks in Braves Country that bemoaned the eve of the season opening trade
that sent Craig Kimbrel to San Diego, I understand the despair.President of Baseball Operations
John Hart swore up and down throughout spring training that he wasn’t
looking to deal away the team’s home grown star, not even after he had
cleaned house in the off-season by making swaps for Jason Heyward,
Justin Upton and Evan Gattis.The fact that Hart fibbed shouldn’t be held against him. It’s what people in sports management
do. Call it the Art of the Smokescreen.But in scanning through Twitter and other forms of social media, there was one theme that seemed to be at the heart – no pun intended – of the Braves fans collective disappointment: Kimbrel was comparable to the greatest closer the game has ever seen: Mariano Rivera.
Those fans need to stop it, and stop it right now.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Kimbrel has four fantastic years to his name. Rivera had 16.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Kimbrel saved 40 games or more in all four of his seasons in Atlanta. Rivera did it nine times, and twice after the age of 40. Kimbrel will be lucky to be still in a major league uniform when he’s 40.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Of Rivera’s record 652 saves, 119 of those were of the more than one inning variety. Kimbrel has zero.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
As we speak, Kimbrel has 186 career saves. For him to pass Rivera, he will average to average 45 saves per season….through 2024.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
Kimbrel has one post-season save to his name. Yes, some of that is the Braves fault for not being able to get him more opportunities. But nonetheless, the number is what it is. One.
Rivera, appropriately enough to match his famous uniform number, has 42 post-season saves.
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera.
So for all of those fine Braves fans who watched Jason Grilli save the season opener in Miami with 95 mph heat, but sat there and complained that he wasn’t Craig Kimbrel… remember this:
Craig Kimbrel is not Mariano Rivera."
===============================
.
The regular season saves record won't be Rivera’s legacy anyway, NYT:
.
3/7/2013, "Next Step for Rivera: Closing a Career," NY Times, Tyler Kepner
"Kimbrel met Rivera last winter, at the New York baseball writers’
dinner, and Rivera gave him one piece of advice: stay healthy.
.
.
The saves
record could fall someday, maybe even to Kimbrel, with a lot of health
and luck.
.
.
The postseason distinguishes Rivera from every other reliever, before or
since. His regular-season earned run average is 2.21. His postseason
E.R.A. — in 96 games against the best competition, under the most
pressure — is 0.70."...
.
.
==================================
.
.
Comment:
Regarding "post season opportunities," not everyone who goes to the post season gets good numbers. Post season pitchers have
shorter off seasons, shorter amounts of time in which to recover for the
next regular season, have pitched under the most pressure, against the
best hitters, often in cold and rain. Rivera pitched until November
4th twice, in 2001 and 2009. His 141 post season innings are the equivalent
of 2 additional years of relief pitching @ 70 IP/yr. These additional 2
years have been pitched within the same calendar years as players who
only played in regular season. The majority of his postseason
appearances were more than 1 inning: "Rivera finished off the eighth inning and pitched the ninth, the 53rd time in the postseason he’s gone more than three outs." (parag. 5). 10/12/2009, "Familiar faces push Yankees to the ALCS," Jeff Passan. After the 2009 ALDS, Rivera added 5 more postseason multi-inning appearances: 2009 ALCS game two, 2.1IP, 2009 ALCS game 6, 2IP, 2009 WS game two, 2IP, 2009 WS game six 1.2IP, and 2010 ALDS game one, 1.1IP (men on 2nd and 3rd). Of his 96 post season appearances, 58 were multi-inning.
These things aren't mentioned with regular season stats or what are called "career" stats.
Per
Baseball Reference, Kimbrel appears to have one
regular season save of more than 3 outs, a 1.1 IP appearance on
8/25/13, entered with a man on first and 3 run lead. I did
want to mention that Mo
has 8 wins in post season, was MVP
of 1999 World Series and 2003 ALCS. He also pitched nine
innings in All Star Games and has a zero ERA.
In 1996 Rivera pitched 107.2 innings in regular season followed by 14.1 innings in post season including 3 days in a row in the World Series (10/21, 10/22, and 10/23) for a total of 122 innings.
Page 208 from Joel Sherman's book, "Birth of a Dynasty," about the 1996 Yankees, published in 2006 by Rodale:
"Most amazingly, of the record 4,962 homers spanked in 1996, Rivera allowed just one,
- to Baltimore's Rafael Palmeiro on June 28."...
Rivera at 2013 Spring Training in Tampa, AP, via NYT
.
